(and I hope to find out about yours too…)

A year or so ago on Facebook I made a list of some of my favorite books of all time. I didn’t say why I cared about my top choices, so I thought I’d do that now. Also, I’d love to know your favorite books, and why you chose them.
Well, Jane Eyre will always be at the top of my list. Nothing can replace it because it impacted me in a huge way. I read it way back in 1965 when I was eighteen years old, and until the moment I got my hands on it I’d only read books by men. Not intentionally, mind you, but because I hadn’t known of any women authors. This was before contemporary women’s fiction started being published in the 1970s and I entered reading heaven. (These 70s women’s books were first put down by patriarchal society as confessional writing and later evolved into being referred to as chick lit. So very sad.)
Anyway, at eighteen I had never been exposed to classic novels, like Jane Eyre or any other women’s classics, and Jane Eyre came to me in a strange “meant to be” kind of way. That is, the novel was left behind by a previous tenant in an empty house my family moved into. It was sitting on the floor in the bedroom I would occupy. I took this to be a spiritual action.
So let me start by saying that I strongly identified with Jane’s life from page one. There was no possibility of taking a walk that day, Charlotte Bronte began her novel, and the words no possibility reached out and grabbed hold of me. I knew by that opening line that Jane in her present state was living in a world of no possibilities, and this mirrored my own sad life. It turned out that Jane lived with her mean Aunt Reed and her nasty-ass cousins who were cruel to her. As for myself, I lived in a household where daily abuse was the norm. Jane was stuck in a world she hated, and I had been too. Therefore, I thought of Jane and I as soul sisters. Here was someone so much like me–and isn’t this what literature does at its finest–allowing the reader to see themselves in a character?
As Jane moved through the pages of her fictional world she little by little grew stronger and stronger. When she arrived at Thornfield Hall where she worked as a nanny, she came upon difficult decisions but she relied on God to guide her. She had morals. She had integrity. She refused to compromise herself. I loved her strength and read this beloved book over and over again.
Lady Oracle by Margaret Atwood was another one of those novels that I dove into head first, and I read it in my late twenties. It’s been decades since I first read about Joan Foster, Margaret Atwood’s main character, but I can still remember being in a book store on Castro Street in San Francisco where I bought it. Once home and reading it, I didn’t stop until I’d finished it at midnight and it was about three hundred pages long. I’d never done that with a novel before–finished it in one day–and the feeling that I got when I turned the last page was one of sadness because I loved the novel so much and regretted that I’d never get the chance to read it for the first time again. Never ever get that experience.
The part that I related to the most was Joan dealing with her weight. This was an era before Jennifer Weiner began publishing her novels that often dealt with large heroines and body image and I was hungry to read of these experiences. I had dealt with being heavyset for most of my life. As a kid I had always been the largest girl in the class, put down by being called fatty. I distinctly remember being in the sixth grade and one of the student’s mothers yelling Look at fatty run! when she was chaperoning the playground. All during my childhood I was told that no boy would ever like me unless I first lost weight which was too bad for me because I had a pretty face. Me and my fat, unloveable. So when I found Joan struggling with issues involving her weight I related to it, her mother being the instigator, and my mother being one of my instigator’s also.
Joan Foster helped me to not feel so alone in the same way that Jane Eyre did, only this time it was about my body size. Here’s a quote from Lady Oracle that stands out in my mind:
A woman’s worth is not determined by her size or shape, but by the strength of her character.
Next up is Carson McCullers’ The Heart Is a Lonely Hunter. I don’t know anyone who has read this book who hasn’t been emotionally moved by it. And I mean deeply moved, their heart exiting the book on a pair of crutches. Oh, the story of John Singer, the deaf mute who everyone confided in. And I was so moved by thirteen-year-old tomboy Mick Kelly, a young teen struggling with loneliness and dreaming of becoming a musician. Mick describes her world as her inner room, and we readers are privy to that psychological room of hers. I felt as if I was right there with her when she ached to take music lessons but had no money for them. She hoped to hear Mozart or Beethoven being played as she walked about her town. I touched her loneliness, felt it, living alongside her.
Next up. Enter May Sarton. To discover May Sarton’s journals was a wonderful experience for me, and there were so many of them that truth be told, they were all pretty similar but I didn’t care. Her journals opened a door to a world of privacy where it felt as if May and I were sitting at a table together and she was telling me about her life rather than writing about it and me laying on the bed and reading it. I felt that close to her, as if I was May’s confidante. Sarton wrote about living alone in an isolated area of New England and finding solace in being hidden away. Being alone didn’t frighten her and I’m pretty much like that. I’m an introvert by nature and do much better by myself than with people. I like people all right, but I fiercely need my alone time in order to feel sane. May went to bed alone, woke up alone and wrote about her pets, her gardening and her writing process. (She also wrote that she was hard to get along with, and I witnessed her crankiness when I met her in person at a reading, but hey, I’d been forewarned.)
Here’s a quote of hers:
I always forget how important the empty days are, how important it may be sometimes not to expect to produce anything, even a few lines in a journal. A day when one has not pushed oneself to the limit seems a damaged, damaging day, a sinful day. Not so! The most valuable thing one can do for the psyche, occasionally, is to let it rest, wander, live in the changing light of a room.
Hemingway’s The Old Man and the Sea also had a soulful effect upon me. The opening line: He was an old man who fished alone in a skiff in the Gulf Stream and he had gone eighty-four days now without taking a fish. So Santiago, the main character, ends up all alone at sea. He’s searching for meaning while searching for a big fish after going a long time without catching one. He needs to prove to his aging self that he still has what it takes. It would have been a whole different book if it had been titled The Young Man and the Sea. Santiago didn’t have that much time left, which increases the urgency. I hadn’t expected to like this book so much, but his quiet endurance, his slow spirituality hooked me, no pun intended. Hemingway made me root for Santiago, wanting him to succeed, involving me in his journey.
And then there’s Steinbeck….
Guys like us, that work on ranches, are the loneliest guys in the world. They got no fambly. They don’t belong no place.
George, from Steinbeck’s Of Mice and Men
Well, just rip my heart out. Two men. George and Lennie. George as caretaker. Lennie with the mind of a child. An unlikely pairing. Two powerless migrant workers with a dream of owning their own land.
Reading about their relationship mesmerized me as I’d never read of such an intense relationship between two men before. Men sharing a common dream, a dream that seemed so unattainable. I identified with their dream of a home. A real home. All my life, until I left home as an older teenager, I had moved around from one place to the next. I had gone to eighteen different schools before graduating from high school as my mother was mentally ill and couldn’t tolerate living in any one place for very long. We were very poor and would get behind on the rent and sometimes would sneak out at midnight with our suitcases. I so wanted to belong to what I considered a normal family, a family who put down roots. And so I saw myself in George and Lennie and shared a dream with them.
Jane, Joan, May, Santiago, George and Lennie.
Please tell me about your favorite characters and books….


